What is the Difference Between Mandatory and Discretionary Spending?
What is the Difference Between Mandatory and Discretionary Spending?
Mandatory spending refers to legally required expenses, such as Social Security, Medicare, and interest on the national debt. These are fixed obligations set by law.
On the other hand, discretionary spending includes expenses that Congress decides through the annual budget process, such as education, defense, and infrastructure. It’s more flexible and subject to change each year.
Mandatory spending makes up about two-thirds of all federal spending and typically continues automatically each year unless an existing law is changed. Since these programs operate under preset legal requirements, they do not require new yearly legislation to continue.
In contrast, discretionary spending requires annual approval from Congress through the appropriations process. If Congress does not pass an appropriations bill, discretionary programs may face funding shortfalls or shutdowns.
Tax legislation is often considered mandatory spending in many parts of the Congressional budget process. Tax laws, like entitlement programs, operate under existing statutes and influence government revenue without requiring annual approval.
Understanding the distinction between mandatory and discretionary spending is essential for analyzing how government resources are allocated and how changes in policy impact federal budgets.
Short on time? Watch a quick explainer video instead 👇
FAQs
What is an example of discretionary spending?
Discretionary spending includes government expenditures that require annual approval by Congress through the appropriations process. Examples include defense spending, education programs, transportation infrastructure, national parks, and public health initiatives.
Since these expenses are not legally mandated, funding can fluctuate based on government priorities and budget negotiations.
What is the difference between essential and discretionary expenses?
Essential expenses are necessary costs that individuals or businesses must pay to maintain basic living or operational needs. These include rent or mortgage payments, utilities, groceries, healthcare, and insurance.
Discretionary expenses, on the other hand, are non-essential costs that can be adjusted based on available income. These include entertainment, travel, dining out, luxury purchases, and subscriptions.
What is the difference between discretionary and non-discretionary spending?
Discretionary spending refers to optional or flexible expenses that can be adjusted or eliminated based on financial circumstances. For individuals, this includes vacations, hobbies, and entertainment.
For governments, it includes military funding, research programs, and infrastructure projects that require annual approval.
Conversely, non-discretionary spending consists of fixed, legally mandated expenses that must be paid regardless of financial conditions. For individuals, this includes rent, utility bills, and loan payments.
For governments, it covers mandatory programs like Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid, which continue unless laws are changed. Non-discretionary spending is essential and typically prioritized over discretionary expenses.
